cmmctrade-pressNewsThe Broadside2 min read

House Small Business panel examines CMMC pause hit on contractors

The freeze stalled the independent verification that was pushing contractors from written policy to demonstrable implementation.


TL;DR

The House Small Business Committee's contracting and infrastructure subcommittee convenes Nov. 18 to examine how CMMC lands on small defense contractors, months after DOD CIO Kirsten Davies paused phase two on July 13. Phase two was set to begin Nov. 11 and require a third-party CMMC Level 2 assessment to compete for defense work. Win-Tech's Allison Giddens warns that firms which paid for certification could lose work to lower-priced competitors who skipped the same investment.

The House Small Business Committee's contracting and infrastructure subcommittee convenes Nov. 18 to hear what CMMC compliance is doing to small defense contractors, and what reform should look like while the Pentagon's phase two sits frozen. DOD CIO Kirsten Davies paused phase two on July 13. It was set to begin Nov. 11 and require a third-party CMMC Level 2 assessment to compete for defense contracts.

The sharpest argument comes from Allison Giddens, president of operations at Win-Tech, who tells the panel the suspension "interrupted important momentum." Her logic is plain: independent verification was already incentivizing contractors to move past written policies and self-reported compliance toward implementation they could actually demonstrate. Freezing it, she argues, risks widening the gap between contractors who invested in proving compliance and those who kept operating under little independent scrutiny.

The competitive risk she names is concrete. If self-assessments remain the default with no credible independent verification, nothing assures every contractor meets the same standard. Firms that paid for certification could lose work to lower-priced competitors who skipped that same investment, what her testimony calls "a competitive advantage for those who have avoided meaningful accountability."

Giddens also pushes back on treating the Pentagon's Brilliant at the Basics initiative as simple. There's "a difference between a cybersecurity concept being basic and its implementation being easy," her testimony says, and she asks Congress to force clarity on how the initiative relates to NIST SP 800-171, CMMC, and independent verification. She recommends a one-time federal tax credit for firms that obtained CMMC Level 2 through an authorized third-party assessment, and wants DOD and the FAR Council to reconcile NIST 800-171 Rev 2 and Rev 3 before adding new requirements.

SmartCert CEO Lyndon Lattie and SD3IT president Dave Dimlich also urge the panel to address CUI marking. Dimlich proposes the government host and fund a protected CUI work environment for small firms, beginning with a pilot, to cut the duplicated infrastructure each firm now builds on its own. Lattie points to H.R. 10288, the Cybersecurity for Small Business Act, which passed the House on Nov. 11 and directs the SBA to issue CMMC guidance for small firms.

It isn't the committee's first look at CMMC. It held a hearing on CMMC costs in 2021, during the internal review that produced CMMC 2.0. Now it convenes months into a phase two freeze, and the witnesses want Congress to force clarity on whether independent verification survives.


Published ·Deep Fathom