ai-cybersecuritytrade-pressNewsThe Broadside2 min read

Hacking Policy Council urges SI Force researcher protections

Intent and disclosure sit at the center of HPC’s ask, because dual-use AI testing looks similar until policy names the difference.


TL;DR

Inside Cybersecurity reports that the Hacking Policy Council used a Nov. 3 blog post to ask the Trump administration’s Super Intelligence Force to prioritize liability exemptions for good-faith security researchers. The task force, launched Oct. 15 after Trump’s Sept. 29 order adopting “super intelligence” terminology, has recommendations due Feb. 10. HPC wants safeguards for high-risk AI capabilities designed so penetration testing, vulnerability research, exploit development and AI model-flaw testing aren’t unnecessarily restricted.

Inside Cybersecurity reports that the Hacking Policy Council is using the Trump administration’s Super Intelligence Force process to make a familiar point in a newer AI wrapper: security research policy has to distinguish intent and conduct, not just tools. HPC’s Nov. 3 blog post asks the task force to prioritize liability exemptions for good-faith researchers as it develops recommendations on adversarial misuse of artificial intelligence capabilities.

The setup matters. Trump signed a Sept. 29 executive order changing federal terminology from artificial intelligence to “super intelligence,” and the White House launched the SI Force on Oct. 15 with recommendations due Feb. 10, according to Inside Cybersecurity. HPC’s submission says the task force should protect legitimate research and consider concrete signs of good faith, including authorization, steps to avoid harm and responsible disclosure.

That’s the practical line HPC wants preserved. The same activity can be defensive testing or malicious tradecraft depending on the actor and the handling of what they find. HPC points to penetration testing, exploit development, vulnerability research and testing AI model flaws as activities used by both good-faith researchers and malicious cyber actors, while arguing that those activities are also needed to identify vulnerabilities before adversaries exploit them.

This isn’t a new institutional position for HPC. The council is described in the article as a group focused on a more favorable legal, policy and business environment for good-faith security research, penetration testing, independent repair for security and vulnerability disclosure management. Inside Cybersecurity has also reported that HPC previously asked the Justice Department to enhance legal protections for AI red teaming and urged CISA to grant exemptions in its upcoming incident reporting regime.

The narrower read is the safer one: HPC isn’t asking the SI Force to bless every researcher claim at face value. It’s asking the task force to build safeguards for high-risk AI capabilities without unnecessarily restricting legitimate security work, and to consult independent researchers, bug bounty platforms, vulnerability management providers and red-teaming specialists while doing so. For federal AI policy, that’s a basic design choice, not a courtesy meeting.


Published ·Deep Fathom