farindependentNewsThe Broadside2 min read

FAR Part 15 proposal drops adverse past-performance notice mandate

The practical fight is timing: ordinary CPARS response opportunities don’t answer whether FAR Part 15 should require source-selection notice.


TL;DR

Covington flags a proposed FAR Part 15 change that would remove the current requirement to raise adverse past-performance information an offeror hasn’t had a chance to answer. Offerors and their counsel would lose a mandatory pre-award exchange when that information keeps them out of the competitive range. The proposal still permits clarifications, but says agencies aren’t required to hold them.

The proposed Revolutionary FAR Overhaul rewrite of FAR Part 15 would turn a mandatory disclosure obligation into agency discretion. Under the existing FAR 15.306 framework, contracting officers must address adverse past-performance information that an offeror hasn’t previously had an opportunity to answer when that information is the determining factor blocking the offeror from the competitive range. During discussions, the rule also requires contracting officers to raise that kind of adverse past-performance information. The current text is still visible in FAR 15.306, including the “shall address” language for competitive-range communications (https://www.acquisition.gov/far/15.306).

Covington’s read of the proposed rule is that this requirement goes away if the FAR Council finalizes the text as written. Proposed FAR 15.202(a)(2)(iii) would make adverse past-performance information a permissible subject for clarifications, but agencies would not be required to conduct clarifications with an offeror. The proposal’s prefatory commentary, as quoted by Covington, says contracting officers could address such information before establishing the competitive range, but would no longer be required to do so as a matter of policy.

That’s a real transparency change, even if it’s narrower than a general right to litigate past performance before award. The old structure forced the government to surface a particular problem at a particular moment: when unresolved adverse past performance was the reason an offeror was not making the competitive range, or when discussions were being held. The proposed structure still lets an agency ask. It just doesn’t appear to make the agency ask.

The caveat matters. Covington notes that offerors often have some opportunity to respond to past-performance information through CPARS or otherwise, so the practical impact may vary by procurement and record. But CPARS practice is not the same question as FAR Part 15 source-selection procedure. The open item for contractors and bid-protest counsel is whether the final rule keeps this discretion, and if it does, how agencies explain a decision to use adverse past performance without first opening the pre-award exchange the current rule requires.


Published ·Deep Fathom