California fines Hertz $1.55M over opt-out signals
Automated opt-out signals are a binding "no" under CCPA, and Hertz just paid $1.55 million for treating them like a suggestion.
TL;DR
The California Privacy Protection Agency fined Hertz $1.55 million Tuesday for not processing the automated opt-out preference signals consumers send from browsers and devices, and for adding friction to the opt-out process. Hertz, which also owns Dollar and Thrifty, agreed to quarterly testing and monitoring and to review new tracking technologies. The agency separately settled with CC Filson Co. for $218,000, ordering it to stop device-based data sales to ad tech firms within 30 days.
California's privacy regulator fined Hertz $1.55 million Tuesday for ignoring the automated opt-out signals consumers send from browsers and devices to tell sites not to sell or share their data. The California Privacy Protection Agency said Hertz, which also runs Dollar and Thrifty, didn't process those preference signals, didn't tell customers how it handled them, and added what the agency called "friction" to the opt-out process. Hertz agreed to the penalty and to quarterly testing and monitoring, a review of new tracking technologies, and opt-out compliance checks.
Automated opt-out signals are not a courtesy; under the California Consumer Privacy Act they function as a binding instruction. The CPPA keeps returning to that line. Tractor Supply paid $1.35 million in September 2025, then the agency's largest-ever fine, for failing to offer opt-outs over data sales and sharing alongside other violations. PlayOn Sports paid $1.1 million in March for making students click through to ad-industry programs instead of offering its own opt-out tool. Hertz's $1.55 million now tops that roster on the opt-out mechanics the agency enforces. The larger $2.75 million Disney settlement came through Attorney General Rob Bonta, not the CPPA.
Alongside Hertz, the agency settled with CC Filson Co. for $218,000, requiring the clothing maker to stop all device-based sales and sharing of personal information to advertising technology firms within 30 days. For a compliance team, the message is the same one CPPA's Acting Deputy Director of Enforcement Lara Kehoe Hoffman put plainly: "Businesses have been on notice for years that we expect them to listen when Californians say no to trackers."
Published ·Deep Fathom